Quick Answer: A furnace replacement in Steubenville, OH typically costs between $4,200 to $7,175 installed. The actual cost depends on the furnace’s efficiency, the features you choose, and the complexity of the installation. At Honest Fix, we break it down into three clear categories: Good, Better, and Best.
Written by Alex Largent, Owner of Honest Fix Heating, Cooling & Plumbing. Alex is a NATE-certified Senior Efficiency Analyst with over 20 years of HVAC experience serving the Upper Ohio Valley.
Why Steubenville Homeowners Ask About Furnace Prices
One of the first questions I hear when a Steubenville homeowner calls me is: “What’s it going to cost me to replace my furnace?” It’s a fair question. A new furnace isn’t like a new coffee maker — it’s a major investment in your home, your family’s comfort, and your monthly utility bills.
Over the years, I’ve seen what happens when people go with the cheapest install. A family in Pleasant Heights once showed me a furnace that failed after just 9 years. The reason? The contractor skipped critical installation steps. When we replaced it with a Better two-stage system, the difference was immediate: steadier heat throughout the home and a 19% drop in their January heating bill.
That’s why furnace pricing isn’t just about equipment — it’s about installation quality and long-term value.
Furnace Replacement Price Ranges in Steubenville
Here’s how we break it down for homeowners:
- Good (Single Stage, 80% Efficiency): $4,200 to $4,600 installed
Best for families who want the lowest upfront cost and reliable, no-frills heating.
- Better (Two Stage, 80–90% Efficiency): $5,400 to $6,050 installed
This is where most homeowners land. It runs at a lower stage most of the time, which means quieter operation, more even comfort, and lower bills.
- Best (High Efficiency, 90%+ Two Stage): $5,700 to $7,175 installed
Ideal for long-term homeowners who want top efficiency, maximum comfort, and the lowest gas bills possible.
➡️ For those who want advanced options, we also install premium systems with variable-speed blowers, advanced humidity control, and ultra-quiet operation.
What Drives Furnace Prices Up or Down?
I often hear: “Why did my neighbor pay a different price than me for a similar furnace?” The answer comes down to efficiency and installation.
- If you choose a 90%+ high-efficiency system, the upfront price will be higher, but your monthly bills will shrink.
- If you go with an 80% system, it’s cheaper upfront but costs more over time.
- Installation can make a huge difference. A furnace swap in a wide-open basement is straightforward. But if we need to rerun ductwork, update gas lines, or squeeze into a crawlspace, labor costs rise.
The biggest cost factor isn’t just the furnace you buy — it’s how it’s installed in your home.
Common Misconceptions in Steubenville
- “Cheapest is always best.” → A low upfront price can cost more later in high energy bills.
- “Every contractor installs the same way.” → Not true. Workmanship can add or subtract years from your furnace’s life.
- “Warranties all cover the same things.” → Most warranties stop at parts. Honest Fix covers labor for up to 15 years.
FAQs: Furnace Replacement in Steubenville
What’s included in Honest Fix’s installation price?
We do the full job: remove the old furnace, install the new one to code, test and start it up, register the warranty, and back it all with our Lifetime Trust Shield.
What guarantees do you provide?
We stand behind our installs with:
- A 15-year labor warranty
- A 90-day satisfaction or money-back guarantee
- A no-lemon replacement policy if the system fails three times in year one
- An energy savings guarantee — at least 15% HVAC energy savings in the first year, or we pay you back
Are you the cheapest in Steubenville?
No. We don’t aim to be. We aim to install furnaces that last and protect you with written guarantees most contractors don’t offer.
Bottom Line
Furnace replacement in Steubenville costs $4,200 to $7,175 installed. Honest Fix customers choose us not because we’re the cheapest, but because we combine transparent pricing, expert installation, and guarantees that protect your comfort and your wallet.
Alex Largent
Alex Largent is the Owner and Senior HVAC Efficiency Analyst at Honest Fix Heating, Cooling & Plumbing. With more than 20 years of field experience, NATE and EPA certifications, and a hands-on leadership style, Alex teaches his team to fix systems right the first time — with transparency, precision, and no upsells. He writes about HVAC diagnostics, home energy efficiency, and practical maintenance advice for homeowners across the Upper Ohio Valley. Read Alex Largent’s full bio to learn more about his expertise in the HVAC and Plumbing industry. Updated October 2025.
